Issue Area: Narrow Range of Debate

Given that most media outlets are owned by for-profit corporations and are funded by corporate advertising, it is not surprising that they seldom provide a full range of debate. The right edge of discussion is usually represented by a committed supporter of right-wing causes, someone who calls for significantly changing the status quo in a conservative direction. The left edge, by contrast, is often represented by an establishment-oriented centrist who supports maintaining the status quo; very rarely is a critic of corporate power who identifies with progressive causes and movements with the same passion as their conservative counterparts allowed to take part in mass media debates.

Next in What's Wrong With the News: Censorship

Extra Articles and Studies
NYT Iraq War ‘Debate’ Excludes Critics: Paper’s panel features nine hawkish ‘experts’ (Update June 2008) By Peter Hart

No Way Out: Withdrawing from withdrawal from Iraq (November/December 2007) By Peter Hart

Terror Talk Crowds Out Thoughtful Discussion: Wiretapping Americans for foreign intelligence (November/December 2007) By Cynthia Cooper

Less...
Self-Inflicted Wounds? (January/February 2007) By Steve Rendall

Think Tank Sources Fall, but Left Gains Slightly: Progressive groups still a small slice (March/April 2007) By Michael Dolny

Staying Inside the Beltway: Sunday shows ignore anti-war voices (Update February 2007) By Jim Naureckas

Old Media’s Election Centrism: It’s not their party and they’ll cry if they want to (Update December 2006) By Jim Naureckas

Nixed Signals: When Hamas hinted at peace, U.S. media wouldn’t take the message (September/October 2006) By Seth Ackerman

More Dangerous Than Anyone Thought: Driving data latest attack on ‘teen brains’ (September/October 2006) By Mike Males

The Power of Conservative Spinning: How the right outguns the left in the PR wars (September/October 2006) By Karl Grossman

Sidebar: Brooks and Shields (September/October 2006) By Steve Rendall and Julie Hollar

Sidebar: The Internet Problem (July/August 2006) By Peter Hart

Sidebar: Another Clinton? (July/August 2006) By Peter Hart

Impeachment Not on Media Radar: Adultery was serious; this is just the Constitution (July/August 2006) By Dave Lindorff

Move Over—Over and Over: Media’s rightward push for Democrats (July/August 2006) By Peter Hart and Steve Rendall

Meet the Oil Executives: Industry-friendly panels on NBC’s Meet the Press (July/August 2006) By Peter Hart

Study Finds First Drop in Think Tank Cites: Progressive groups see biggest decline (May/June 2006) By Michael Dolny

Fear & Favor 2005 -- The Sixth Annual Report: Outside (and inside) influence on the news (March/April 2006) By Julie Hollar and Janine Jackson and Hilary Goldstein

"Our Media Refuse to Name This Reality": Jonathan Kozol on resegregated education (March/April 2006)

Failing at Its "No. 1 Goal": Lack of balance at C-SPAN’s Washington Journal (November/December 2005) By Steve Rendall

Judgment Reserved to Judgment Reversed: Swift Boat, NARAL ads show media double standard (November/December 2005) By Julie Hollar

Sidebar: Face-Off (November/December 2005) By Steve Rendall

Time to Unplug the CPB: Replace corrupt board with independent trust (September/October 2005) By Steve Rendall and Peter Hart

The Military-Industrial-Media Complex: Why war is covered from the warriors’ perspective (July/August 2005) By Norman Solomon

Opinion Omission: Women hard to find on op-ed pages, TV panels (May/June 2005) By Julie Hollar

Stand by Your Man: Mostly male pundits defend male-dominated science (May/June 2005) By Jessica Wakeman and Julie Hollar

Right, Center Think Tanks Still Most Quoted: Study of cites debunks “liberal media” claims (May/June 2005) By Michael Dolny

The Great Emancipator: Media credit Bush for “democratization” of the Mideast (May/June 2005) By Peter Hart

A 'Right-Wing Coup': Against PBS's Mythical Bias (Update June 2005) By Peter Hart and Steve Rendall

Something to Get Worked Up About (Update June 2005)

I Was Right All Along: You can look it up—but better not (May/June 2005) By Peter Hart

Rather's Real Bias: He slanted toward power, not the left (Update April 2005) By Peter Hart

Fear & Favor 2004 -- The Fifth Annual Report: How power shapes the news (March/April 2005) By Peter Hart and Julie Hollar

The Real Lessons of "Memogate" (Update February 2005) By Peter Hart and Jim Naureckas

Struggling MSNBC Attempts to Out-Fox Fox (Update February 2005) By Peter Hart

The Fairness Doctrine: How we lost it, and why we need it back (January/February 2005) By Steve Rendall

Meet the Stenographers: Press shirks duty to scrutinize official claims (November/December 2004) By Steve Rendall

I'm Not a Leftist, But I Play One on TV: Progressives excluded as right battles center (September/October 2004) By Steve Rendall and Anne Kosseff

Not Even the New Republic (September/October 2004) By Steve Rendall and Anne Kosseff

How Public Is Public Radio?: A study of NPR’s guest list (May/June 2004) By Steve Rendall and Daniel Butterworth

Special Report: Think Tank Coverage: More attention, but not more balance (May/June 2004) By Michael Dolny

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (March/April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

'A Loose Cannon Experience': Which opinions need balancing on the NewsHour? (Update April 2004) By Peter Hart

Target Dean: Re-establishing the establishment (March/April 2004) By Peter Hart

Why Progressive TV Is DOA: Editor's Note (November/December 2003) By Jim Naureckas

Weeding the Field: Press tries to determine who should and shouldn't run for president (September/October 2003) By Jacqueline Bacon

Spectrum Narrows Further in 2002: Progressive, domestic think tanks see drop (July/August 2003) By Michael Dolny

CNN's Reliably Narrow Sources: Media show's exclusive guestlist reinforces biases (March/April 2003) By Steve Rendall

White Noise: Voices of color scarce on urban public radio (September/October 2002) By Steve Rendall and Will Creeley

Power Sources: On party, gender, race and class, TV news looks to the most powerful groups (May/June 2002) By Ina Howard

Canada’s Media Monopoly: One perspective is enough, says CanWest (May/June 2002) By James Winter

Think Tanks in a Time of Crisis: FAIR's 2001 survey of the media's institutional experts (March/April 2002) By Michael Dolny

Bias Short on Substance: Former CBS reporter claims TV has "leftward" slant (March/April 2002) By Peter Hart and Steve Rendall

Covering the Horserace, Not the Track: The press shortchanges electoral reform (January/February 2002) By Rob Richie

Patriotism & Censorship: Some journalists are silenced, while others seem happy to silence themselves (November/December 2001) By Peter Hart and Seth Ackerman

The Op-Ed Echo Chamber: Little or no space for dissent from the military line (November/December 2001) By Steve Rendall

What's Not Talked About on Sunday Morning?: Issues of corporate power are not on the agenda (September/October 2001) By George Farah and Justin Elga

Fox's Slanted Sources: Conservatives, Republicans far outnumber others (July/August 2001) By Steve Rendall

The Most Biased Name in News: Fox News Channel's extraordinary right-wing tilt (July/August 2001) By Seth Ackerman

Election Night Meltdown: Media monopoly contributed to exit-poll errors (January/February 2001) By Steve Rendall

Nader the Nightmare: Media come to the aid of the two-party system (January/February 2001) By Peter Hart

Nader and the Press: Condescension Turns Nasty (Update October 2000) By Jim Naureckas

Mainstream News Coverage Of Economics: Elite Bias Rules (3/1/00) By Jeff Cohen

Rally 'Round the Boys: PBS's National Desk enlists in the 'gender wars' (September/October 1999) By Jennifer L. Pozner

The Ever-Present Yet Nonexistent Poor: For Heritage's Poverty Expert, Numbers Mean What He Says They Mean (January/February 1999) By Seth Ackerman

Doublethink on the Editorial Page: Editorials preach compassion, push austerity (July/August 1998) By Janine Jackson

Field Guide to TV's Lukewarm Liberals: How to spot centrist pundits served up as the "left" (July/August 1998)

What's in a Label?: Right-wing think tanks are often quoted, rarely labeled (May/June 1998) By Michael Dolny

New Survey on Think Tanks: Media Favored Conservative Institutions in 1996 (July/August 1997) By Michael Dolny

The Media's Favorite Think Tank: How the Heritage Foundation Turns Money into Media (July/August 1996) By Norman Solomon

The Think Tank Spectrum: For the Media, Some Thinkers Are More Equal Than Others (May/June 1996) By Michael Dolny

Crossfire: Still Missing a Space on the Left (Update April 1996) By Jim Naureckas

The Pundit Spectrum: How Many Women--and Which Ones? (November/December 1995) By Laura Flanders

Media to Smithsonian:: History Is Bunk (Update April 1995)

Foundations for a Movement: How the right wing subsidizes its press (March/April 1995) By Beth Schulman

'Move to the Right': Pundits' Tried-and-Failed Advice (January/February 1995) By Jim Naureckas

Conventional Wisdom: How the Press Rewrites Democratic Party History Every Four Years (September 1992) By Jim Naureckas

Public TV Tilts Toward Conservatives: Brought to You By... (June 1992)

On the Campaign Trail: Public logic vs. press logic (April/May 1992) By Joshua Meyrowitz

Brookings: Stand-In for the Left: Too Many Conservative Columnists, Says Conservative (Special Gulf War Issue 1991) By Lawrence Soley

Media on the March: Journalism in the Gulf (November/December 1990) By Jim Naureckas

TV's Imposters: Television's Political Spectrum (July/August 1990) By Jeff Cohen

Propaganda from the Middle of the Road: The Centrist Ideology of the News Media (October/November 1989) By Jeff Cohen

Fear & Loathing at the Democratic Convention (July/August 1988)

Radio Broadcasts
Gerald LeMelle on Obama in Africa, Katha Pollitt on Caitlin Flanagan in Time (7/17/09)

Stan Karp on No Child Left Behind, Robert Greenwald on Rethink Afghanistan (5/1/09)

Robert Parry on conservative bias, Brandon Lacy Campos on digital TV conversion (2/20/09)

Action Alerts and Advisories
NYT Slams Single-Payer: Fails to include advocates among 'diverse' experts (9/22/09)

Misquoting Sotomayor: Media let right-wing critics frame debate (6/2/09)

Lehrer's Debate Ignores World's Vast Majority (9/29/08)

Less...
Military Atrocities Less Newsworthy Than Right-Wing Fantasies: Press follows smears of New Republic as Nation's evidence of abuse ignored (8/6/07)

USA Today's 'Sicko' Debate: Is Michael Moore wrong...or very wrong? (6/29/07)

Treated Like a Democrat: GOP candidate Ron Paul's 'unorthodox' 9/11 theory (5/31/07)

Democratic Excess: Media find too many candidates—at only one debate (5/8/07)

Staying Inside the Beltway: Networks' Sunday shows ignore public opposition to war (1/29/07)

Ombud Concurs on NewsHour's Iraq Panel: 'I'm with viewers' on imbalance, Getler says (1/16/07)

Debating the Iraq "Surge" on PBS: NewsHour panel skews against public opinion (1/10/07)

Withdrawing From Debate on Iraq: Public's view too 'extreme' for media discussion (12/4/06)

Morning-After Pundits Take Winners to Task: Victorious Dems lectured by media establishment (11/9/06)

PBS Responds to FAIR NewsHour Study (10/18/06)

NY1 Responds to FAIR: Cable station stands by debate rules (8/23/06)

NY1 Dismisses Calls for Tasini-Clinton Debate (8/18/06)

NY1 Silences Debate: Refuses to allow Clinton challenger Tasini in television primary debate (8/4/06)

Warning Dems Against Withdrawal: NY Times paints Iraq vote as boon for Republicans (6/16/06)

C-SPAN Slanting Right: Washington Journal's guestlist lacks balance (12/19/05)

LA Times Dumps Liberal Columnist: Scheer out as Bush attacks Iraq War critics (11/17/05)

NBC Chief: Liberals Don't Watch TV: Does this explain MSNBC's right-leaning lineup? (11/15/05)

Too Many Liberals?: Olbermann says MSNBC bosses upset by liberal guests (10/27/05)

CBS Explains All-GOP Panel: Wanted to avoid "partisan fight" (10/7/05)

CBS's One-Sided DeLay Discussion: All-Republican panel discusses a "Republican problem" (10/4/05)

FAIR Calls for De-Funding CPB: How to REALLY save PBS: Replace corrupt board with independent trust (10/3/05)

NPR's Dvorkin Responds on "Extremist" Label (9/30/05)

Still Covering for Wal-Mart: ABC report has no space for critics (9/23/05)

NPR's "Extremists": Do only "extremist groups" connect war and terror? (9/21/05)

MSNBC's Pro-Bush "Town Meeting" (6/29/05)

Matthews: Labor Doesn't Want to Debate (6/27/05)

CNN's New Boss: Progressives 'Don't Get Too Worked Up About Anything' (4/12/05)

Women's Opinions Also Missing on Television: Women of color virtually invisible on Sunday shows (3/24/05)

ABC Muddles the Social Security Debate: Not "everyone agrees" with distorted claims (1/14/05)

MSNBC's Rightward Slant on Debate Coverage (10/12/04)

NPR Responds to FAIR's NPR Study (6/1/04)

In Iraq Crisis, Networks Are Megaphones for Official Views (3/18/03)

Op-Ed Echo Chamber: Little space for dissent to the military line (11/2/01)

Who's On the News?: Study shows network news sources skew white, male & elite (1/1/01)

FAIR PRESS RELEASE: New Study: CENTER/RIGHT THINK TANKS DOMINATE NEWS (6/13/00)

Does PBS Consider Women Part of the Public?: Biased Series Spurs Meeting With PBS; FAIR Organizes Feminist Coalition for National Campaign (11/12/99)

The Cost of Survival: Political Discourse and the "New PBS" (6/1/99) By William Hoynes

Slanted Sources in NewsHour and Nightline Kosovo Coverage (5/5/99)

MSNBC's 'New' Lineup: Same Old Right-Wing Hosts (2/5/99)

Examining the "Liberal Media" Claim: Journalists' Views on Politics, Economic Policy and Media Coverage (July/August 1998) By David Croteau

Rare Voice for Peace Fired by Washington Post (1/8/97)

Are You on the Nightline Guest List? (2/6/89)

Links:

  • Institute for Public Accuracy